Accommodations fill quickly on Fire Island and only a few towns offer hotels or b&b's, so try and make your reservations before February of that year.
One of the best things about Fire Island is its refuge from hotel life itself. There are few planned activities, room service is unheard of, and bellboy's don't have jobs here. You can go almost anywhere without shoes and dressing for dinner means a comfortable shirt and nice shorts. Of course if you want to go formal you can wear pants.
Hotels/Bed and Breakfasts
Fire Island Pines
The Madison Fire Island Pines
Pines Bluff Overlook
Short-term Shares are available in various packages. All rooms are recently renovated, have private baths, air-conditioning, TV/DVD, bar refrigerators, and private access to the outside deck. Check-out our rates and call with your particular needs or a special occasion. Great winter packages are also available.
Pines Paradise Bed and Breakfast
Phone: 212.368.7058 or 631.597.4130
Fire Island Pines, NY 11782
"Fire Island’s finest gay guest accommodations"
Hip beachside motel and a quasi-hippie hangout look with its unfinished pine siding.
Singles & Doubles $150-$375
Hotel Ciel is the only hotel in the Fire Island Pines Harbor. Stay where the action is. Located in the central hub of the Pines, you will be just steps away from restaurants, bars, cafes, shopping, and, of course, the beach! Balconies have beautiful harbor views and a cool bay breeze. Book your stay now, as the hotel tends to fill up on summer weekends. There is a two-night minimum stay for all weekends, and a three-night minimum stay for all holiday weekends. We can't wait to see you!
Phone: 631-597-6500 ex 35
The Ocean View - Tequila Jacks
Kismet Inn & Marina
Belvedere Guest House For Men
It is in the style of a Venetian Palace, with terraces, towers, domes, statuary, antiques and fountains. A roof-top terrace and bay front deck affords spectacular views of the Great South Bay, the ocean, and towns; sunsets are magnificent. The Belvedere has sun decks, swimming pool, hot tub, a gym, high speed wireless Internet connection, and a television room. They supply ice, coffee, and refrigerators. We serve a complimentary Continental breakfast on Sundays. The Belvedere is a gay clothing optional resort for men.
As you wander the boardwalks of "The Grove" you’ll discover lush tunnels of entwined greenery and houses as whimsical as its residents. In the center of it all is the friendly Grove Hotel. With its convenient "downtown" location, the Grove Hotel is only steps away from the best beaches, shops, dance clubs, bars, and restaurants that Fire Island has to offer.
For listing and reviews of cherry grove accommodations check out: CherryGrove.com
Ocean Bay Park
Seashore Condo Motel
The Seashore Condo Motel is located in Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island. Steps from the Bay, Ocean, and Ferry it provides a unique and fun Fire Island Beach vacation experience. Summer, Sun, and the Atlantic Ocean make for the ideal vacation lodging for singles, couples and families. Our comfortable, air-conditioned hotel rooms provide all the comforts you expect from a relaxing, carefree and happy beach vacation.
Fire Island Hotel and Resort
With a wide variety of room styles, the Fire Island Hotel can accommodate parties of all sizes. Their newly renovated rooms include private marble baths and private decks with Ocean or Poolside views.
The Palms Hotel
Room Features: Flat Screen TVs, Refrigerators, iPod Docking Stations, Egyptian Cotton Sheets, Satellite TV, Wi-Fi Hotspot, and All Non-Smoking Rooms. Ferry Service from Bay Shore, NY, Limousine and Town car Transportation. Close to shopping, nightlife, and entertainment, Short walk to the beach. Event Coordinator on site for Corporate Meetings, Conventions, Weddings, Anniversaries, and Birthdays. Other features include rooms with private baths, Rooms with hall baths, Outdoor hot and cold shower, Open patio with barbeques, Beach chairs and umbrellas, and wagons are available
Phone: (631) 583-8870
Housers Hotel On The Bay
Open since 1921 this is the oldest hotel on the island. Don’t expect to find many amenities, however. If you’re looking for more than air conditioning, ceiling fans and color TV, this is not your gig.
Seasons Bed & Breakfast
Place In The Sun
Open May through October. Two-night minimum stay on Friday and Saturday nights: double occupancy with shared bath.